Project Management
Assessment
item 3 — Group presentation
Weighting:
|
20%
|
Length:
|
15 minutes; Maximum 15
slides for presentation (see details below)
|
Overview
of assignment requirements
This is a group assignment
for the students.Your presentation can be
about:
1. Any area of project
management that is related to the weekly topics and adds a significant body of new
material, a different perspective or depth to the information already covered
in the course lecture material. It is important that you extend your knowledge
and that of the class beyond what will be covered in this unit during the term.
There is scope
to research and present more information about many of the weekly topics. For
example, in the Quality Management week students may wish to investigate Six
Sigma further or ICT students may wish to cover more detail about quality
management in the Software Engineering discipline.
2. Any other topic that is
related to project management that is approved
by your tutor.
Some suggested topics are
shown below. Remember it is only a 15 minute presentation so you have to decide
what aspects of a topic you are going to focus on in your presentation. Some
topics below have more content than could be covered in a 15 minute
presentation (e.g. procurement management). In that case the tutor may allow different groups to focus on different
sub-topics.
You are expected to find
appropriate reference material (at least three, good, recent, relevant
references).
Remember to relate your
presentation to managing a project and explain the significance of your content
to project management. Often this is best illustrated with examples from your
experience or actual project management scenarios.
a. International Projects: This is a chapter from the text book that is
not covered in this course, so aspects of this topic would be appropriate for
your presentation. You can read this chapter get an overview and understanding
of this area. Some of the areas that could be discussed in your presentation
are:
· What additional
challenges are there when you are involved in managing an international
project?
· What is culture shock
and what are strategies for coping with culture shock?
·
How do you select and
train personnel to work on international projects
·
What are cross-cultural
considerations?
b. Outsourcing/Procurement
Management: There is a chapter on outsourcing
in the text book that is not covered in this unit. Some of the areas that could be discussed in
your presentation are:
· What is outsourcing and
what are the advantages/disadvantages of outsourcing?
· What is an RFP and what
is involved in selection of a contractor?
· What are best practices
in outsourcing project work?
· Discuss the art of
negotiation
· What are the different
contract types and their risks (from the contractor and customer perspective)?
What is the “point of total assumption” and how do you calculate this?
c. Leadership:
For example:
·
Different leadership
styles
·
The types of power
leaders use
·
How to learn to be a
good leader and what makes a good leader
·
Stephen Covey and improving effectiveness
d. Human resource
management: For example:
· Motivation Theories
(e.g. Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, Herzberg’s Motivation-Hygiene Theory,
McClelland’s Acquire-Needs Theory, McGregor Theory X and Y, Ouchi’s theory z
etc.)
·
Developing the Project
Team
i.
Training
ii.
Team-building
Activities
iii.
Different “personality
types”: Myers-Briggs Type Indicator, The
Social Style Profile, DISC
e. Quality Management: Quality management in only briefly introduced
in the unit. There are a number of topics within the broad area of quality
management that could be covered in more depth. For example:
·
Tools and Techniques
for Quality control
·
Six Sigma
f. Agile Project Management:
Agile project management is introduced in this unit. However there is scope to
extend this topic. For example
· discussion of
alternative agile PM methodologies (e.g. Kanban, Scrumban)
· Scaled Agile Framework
· DevOps (Agile
development and operations)
g. Effective Communication:
For example
·
Keys to good
communication?
·
Use of technology to
enhance communication
·
Running Effective
Meetings
·
Using E-mail, Texting
and collaborative tools effectively
·
What makes a good
presentation?
h.
Software
Tools and Systems for Project Management
i. Systems Engineering and
Project Management: Topics to be covered
could include:
·
What is Systems
Thinking?
·
What is Systems
Engineering?
·
What are the dimensions
of Systems Engineering?
·
What is the Systems
Life Cycle?
·
What is the relevance
of Systems Engineering to Project Management?
j. Value Management:
For example:
·
What is value
management?
·
What are the benefits
of value management?
·
What industries use
value management?
In this assignment, you
can also draw from your experiences and incorporate them into the assignment.
If you don’t have any work/project experience, that’s fine too. You can also take the opportunity to be
controversial and find academic and trade literature that challenges an aspect
of the material you are presenting. Pose
questions – make your audience think. Both
on-campus and off-campus student, are required to produce the script for the
presentation that should include some potential questions and responses
indicating where you would pose questions to engage your audience. In addition,
the end of the script is to include three potential questions (with their
answers) that you would anticipate being asked by your audience at the end of
the presentation.
Marking
Guide for Assessment item 3
– Presentation
Criteria
|
Available Marks
|
1. Presentation structure:
|
|
a. Introduction.
Introduce the speakers
and the topic (make it clear what you plan to talk about in the
presentation – remember the 3Ts).Aim to engage your
audience from the beginning of the presentation.
This mark also
considers first impressions created by
the speakersBe professional in your
behaviour and appearance. Be prepared early.
|
2 marks
|
b. Body.
Marks will be given for the quality
of the content and correct referencing of the sources of the
material. The content must expand the knowledge of the class
beyond the scheduled lecture material for the course.
Marks are
also based on the flow and fluency of the presentation.
|
5 marks
|
c. Conclusion.
Summarise the key points and
conclusions.(Remember the 3Ts –summarise and conclude)
|
2 mark
|
2.Questions facilitating discussion
during the presentation and at the end
of the presentation
This
includes marks for questions to be posed to the audience during the
presentation and for the three proposed “audience questions and answers” at
the end of the presentation. Each student should be responsible for at least
one of these questions.
Note that for on-campus students the
final 3 questions can be discussed in class if there is time after audience
questions.
|
2 marks
|
3. Delivery and coping with questions/facilitating
discussion.
Marks for
delivery of the material. For on campus students this will also include how
well students handled questions from the audience. Each group member should
be responsible for answering questions for a section of the presentation. If
appropriate, other group members can also contribute to the answer after the
student responsible has been given an opportunity to answer.
|
4 marks
|
4. Visual aids (e.g. slides), summary handout, script.
Marks for quality of the slides,
quality of the script and a good
summary handout with the reference list. For on campus students this must be
provided to students in the class on the day of the presentation.
|
3 marks
|
5. Timing
Timing must be within the range of
13 – 15 minutes.
|
2 marks
|
6. Contribution to the group
This document must be submitted by all
groups before the work can be marked. It is compulsory for all groups.
|
|
Total out of 20 marks
|
[These criteria are
described in more detail in the notes on the following pages.]
Notes
1. Presentation
structure:
a. Introduction:
·
greet the audience courteously
·
title/topic made clear
·
purpose of the presentation is clear
·
issues to be discussed are outlined
·
unusual terms defined adequately.
Speaker/presentation appearance and
other first impressions:
· appropriate standard of dress for the occasion (tidy and free
of distracting features)
·
first impression was one of confidence and poise
·
speaker appeared confident and purposeful before starting to
speak
·
speaker attracted audience’s attention from the outset
·
little or no fidgeting and few distracting mannerisms
·
presentation format is simple, clear and appealing
· For off-campus students this will be marked on the basis of
their recording, script and PowerPoint slide presentation.
b. Body of presentation:
· each issue from the Intro is discussed simply and clearly,
and conclusions/recommendations made, if relevant
·
sufficient information and detail are provided
·
sufficient periodic recapitulation
·
appropriate and adequate use of examples/anecdotes
·
discussion flowed logically.
·
the material is relevant
and new
· good sources of reference material were used to prepare the
presentation
·
references included (and reference slide included at the end)
c.
Conclusion:
·
ending of presentation signalled adequately
·
main points summarised adequately - ideas brought to fruition
· conclusion linked to Introduction and follow from discussion
in the Body
·
final message is clear and easy to remember
·
opportunity for questions from the audience
·
reference slide included at the end
1. Questions facilitating
discussion during the presentation and
at the end of the presentation
· Inclusion of questions designed to facilitate discussion with
an appropriate response (or possible responses) for each question. These are to
be included during the presentation to engage with the audience. They must be
shown clearly in the script.
· Any questions slide at the end of the presentation. Students
must propose at least three questions that might be posed by the audience with
an appropriate response to each of the questions.
2. Delivery and coping with
questions/facilitating discussion:
Delivery:
·
speech clear and audible to entire audience
·
suitable vocabulary (few clichés, little jargon and
repetition)
·
interesting variety in tone of voice
·
clarity and quality of pronunciation
·
little false or excessive use of spoken emphasis
·
short comprehensible sentences
·
presentation directed to all parts of audience
(on-campus presentation)
· eye contact held with audience throughout the presentation
(on-campus presentation)
·
meaningful gestures appropriately used
·
full text not read
·
each speaker kept to his/her time
limit (start on time and finish within the time frame)
·
good use of time without rushing at the end
·
pace neither too fast or too slow
·
showed enthusiasm
·
audience rapport (e.g. approachable)
Coping with questions/facilitating the discussion (relevant
to on-campus students0:
·
interact with the audience courteously
·
invited audience to ask questions
·
whole audience searched for questions
·
ability to listen
·
questions answered in order
·
questions handled adeptly
·
full audience addressed with answers
·
speaker maintained control of discussion
·
“any questions slide”
4. Visual aids (slides), summary handout, script
·
visual aids clearly
visible to entire audience
·
overhead/slide projector/computer,
equipment etc. operated correctly
·
speaker familiar with own visual aids
· visual aids well–prepared (content well-presented
on the slides, not too cluttered, slides consistent, easy to read, good use of
diagrams and images, bullet points to show key points etc.)
· effective use of handouts and/or visual aids
(i.e. integrated into the presentation)
· handouts well–prepared
and useful – a good summary and with reference list
· Script clear and well
written. Script must make it clear how each part of the script relates to the
slides. Questions and answers must be easy to find within the script. (see criteria
2).
5. Timing
· The timing of the presentation must be within the
range 13- 17 minutes and ideally 15 minutes in length. If it is longer than 17
minutes, the tutor will be required to interrupt your presentation. All students
in the group are responsible for ensuring that the timing for the overall
presentation falls within this range.
6. Contribution to the group
· All groups must submit this document before marks
can be awarded. It may be taken into consideration when marking each student’s
work.
·
Examples of the tasks for this assessment item
are
-
researching the topic
-
developing the slides,
-
producing the handout, printing the handout,
-
developing the script
-
developing the embedded questions and answers
-
developing the final “any questions” questions
-
practicing the presentation
·
Note that more than one student can contribute to each task.
For example, each student should be
responsible for researching the topic and finding appropriate references. All members of the group should work
together to make sure that the introduction, body and conclusion flow and are appropriate. It is also acceptable (and
expected) that all students will be involved in all or most of the tasks. It is
also acceptable to give an indication of each student’s contribution to each
task (e.g. 30%, 50%).
Comments
Post a Comment